Court to re-examine ban of large cruise ships in Venice

By Tom Stieghorst
An Italian regional administrative court suspended the order restricting large cruise ships in Venice until a hearing on the issue in June.

The court said alternative routes for cruise ships have not been determined.

In November, the government moved to ban cruise ships of more than 96,000 gross tons from the Giudecca Canal en route to the main cruise docks operated by Venezia Terminal Passeggeri (VTP). That limit was scheduled to take effect in November 2014Court .

The order also cut back the number of ships more than 40,000 gross tons using the route, effective January 2014.

An appeal was filed by VTP, several port businesses and a cruise line operators committee.

According to Italian newspaper Gazetta del Sud, a hearing to further consider the ban is scheduled for June 12.

Lines await effect of plan to slash Venice cruise ship traffic

Lines await effect of plan to slash Venice cruise ship traffic

By Tom Stieghorst

Italy’s decision to constrain cruise ship growth in Venice will likely change the way some cruise passengers enter and leave the city as it is phased in over the next few years.

Prime Minister Enrico Letta approved plans to limit or shut down cruise ship traffic in parts of the Venice lagoon.

His order is at least a partial victory for the No Grandi Navi (No Big Ships) movement that sprang up in Venice as megaships began to visit the city.

And it is a setback, at least for now, for cruise lines.

“This would certainly be a disappointing outcome from our perspective,” Carnival Corp. said in a statement, which went on to assert that “the cruise industry is an important economic driver for Venice and other communities around the world.”

The ruling does not ban cruise ships from docking in Venice, but it places restrictions on how many ships can transit the Guidecca Canal, which takes passengers past the city’s iconic St. Mark’s Plaza.

Starting in January, it requires a 20% reduction in the passage of ships larger than 40,000 gross tons. It limits the number of large ships that can dock at the city’s main cruise terminal, Venezia Terminal Passeggeri, to five per day, according to European press reports.

By November 2014, ships over 96,000 gross tons would no longer be permitted in the Guidecca canal.

In its statement, Carnival said that while no changes are currently being planned, “we will evaluate the ruling and see how it impacts our business in the long run.”

Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd. also responded to the ruling, saying that it is reviewing its deployments for 2013 and 2014 to be sure they comply with the new regulations.

“We recognize visiting Venice during their cruise is a highlight of our guests’ vacation,” Royal stated. “We expect to continue with our scheduled port calls to Venice for our 2013 and 2014 itineraries.”

Last year, 661 cruise ships bearing 1.7 million passengers called at Venezia Terminal Passeggeri. No breakdown of ship size was immediately available.

For the industry, Venice has become a vital turnaround port, uniquely serving both western and eastern Mediterranean itineraries.

For the city, that means extra revenue. Cruise ship passengers and crews spend $255 million a year in Venice, according to a 2013 Cruise Market Watch study, ranking it eighth among world cruise ports and third in Europe, behind Barcelona and Rome (Civitavecchia).

Practically, the decision will first affect deployment decisions for 2015. Neither Carnival nor Royal has announced its 2015 itineraries. The squeeze would be most acute in the summer months when ships tend to migrate to the Med.

One solution is to develop a new channel to Venezia Terminal Passeggeri for large ships that bypasses the most historic part of Venice. Letta’s office said the order restricting ship size also authorized development of such a channel.

However, that would end the romantic entrance to the city past St. Mark’s Plaza, which is treasured by many cruise passengers.

Cruise lines working with authorities over Venice lagoon debate

Cruise lines working with authorities over Venice lagoon debate

By Hollie-Rae Merrick

Cruise lines working with authorities over Venice lagoon debateCruise lines are working with Italian authorities to look at the option of moving the port in Venice to another part of the canal after concerns over the ships’ impact on the city.

Speaking at a Clia press conference earlier today, Pierfrancesco Vago, executive chairman of MSC Cruises, said the industry was working with officials to find a solution and was looking at different canals to establish which would be the best alternative.

His comments came just days after protesters delayed a procession of cruise ships for over an hour by leaping into Venice’s Guidecca canal. The demonstrators believe the cruise ships are threatening the city’s foundations and want the port moved to an island away from the city.

Vago said the issue was “deeply emotional” for some Venetians, however the majority support the cruise lines calling at the destination.

He said there was no environmental impact on Venice by the vessels as cruise lines had already agreed to have a low sulphur admission on entering the city.

Vago said lines and authorities were looking at the ecosystems in the waters surrounding Venice to establish whether there was an alternative and appropriate route.

He added: “We (the cruise industry) are important to the city of Venice, everybody understands that.

“One shop out of six lives because of the cruise industry, 33% of the hotel industry lives because of the cruise industry. It is an emotional impact.”

Howard Frank, Carnival Corporation’s vice chairman and chief operating officer said he agreed that the issue was not a environmental one.

He said the industry needed to do a better job in getting the message out about how environmentally friendly cruise ships had become.